10 predictions for digital payments in 2019

2018 was an exciting year for payments in Nigeria. Tons of cash came in as international investments; interbank transfer crossed 700 million transactions, even mCash had a little showing. Of course, the bitcoin bubble made a loud burst with many licking their wounds.

As usual, the following are my 10 predictions for 2019. They are mostly influenced by my understanding of the industry, discussion with various stakeholders, and my penchant for foolery. While these 10 predictions could be a guide for you, rely on them at your own risk.

#1 Interbank transfers overtake ATM cash transactions
Come April 2019, for the first time ever and every month forever after, Nigerians will do more interbank transfers (using USSD, mobile, and online banking) than they collect money from ATM machines. Interbank has seen a steady 100% annual growth over the last few years and is poised to eclipse other payment methods as more bank customers gravitate towards USSD or can afford smartphones.

#2 Payment Service Banking flops
The euphoria around Payment Service Banks (PSB) is unfounded as it is more about financial inclusion than fancy mobile or digital banking. Nevertheless, the poison pill of 22% CRR and 75% deposit with CBN as Treasury Bills is marking this as dead-on-departure. While a lot have applied, only a few will launch. MTN will find that it’s a different kettle of fish and would struggle significantly.

#3 SANEF becomes a surprising success
Shared Agency Network Expansion Facility is a massive N32B undertaking by banks and NIBSS to haul in 30 million financially excluded Nigerians into the financial ecosystem. While it has been on for months with little to show apart from daily adverts by NIBSS, there appear to be unseen moves to make it a success. For example, the adoption of a common API standard for account opening would help the super agents get to the market faster. The appointment of Ronke Kuye, a veteran of payments and a co-founder of CeBIH, to run SANEF is a significant step in the right direction.

#4 A massive data breach or fraud hits some fintechs
Some months ago, someone found exposed data about Arik customers which included card details, phones, and emails. This discovery underscores how pervasive the security lapses have been for technology companies worldwide. When you hear about likes of Google, Facebook, and Yahoo having breaches, you know it’s a matter of time that a Nigerian bank, a fintech, or government agency is walloped. This time around, it would be a hit so hard they cannot sweep the stories under the carpet. By the way, some of these frauds would be done by internal teams.

#5 CBN clamps down on errant fintechs
After the embarrassing frauds and data breaches, CBN will go into a knee-jerk reaction and go after banks and/or fintechs who do not have licenses. A lot of apps will disappear with many investors dollars following the pipe into the drain.

#6 Interbank transfer becomes N20
CBN will update its rules to force banks to reduce their interbank transfer payments to N20 a pop. Bill payments and others will not change though.

#7 Micropayments become free
Part of the CBN rule would say that transfers below N1,000 should not be charged subject to a maximum of N2,000 per day to engender financial inclusion and cashless payments. Customers will rejoice, and I will throw a party (just make sure you RSVP). Before you think I am mad, just remember that CBN made ATM withdrawal free in 2013 and only put a cap of 3 free transactions when banks went begging with their grandmothers. With the cost of interbank transfer down to N20 or even zero for transactions of N1,000 and below, micropayments will explode. Now you can pay for Agege bread with N50, and you won’t get charged.

#8 International players go big
WhatsApp finally figures out how to connect your bank account (for some banks) to your app so you can now transfer funds instantly to anyone. And guess what, they will do it so well and so seamlessly that you wonder if our banks have been playing.

#9 CBN does an about-turn on the new licensing regime
The Central Bank of Nigeria recently threw some gasoline into the fintech fire when it proposed to create 3 licensing bands of up to N5B capital requirements. Since then, everyone has been snipping at CBN’s heels.

#10 Someone hacks AI for banking
A smart bank finally figures out what to do with the mess that WhatsApp banking. Instead of the rubbish flow, you will now be able to chat using natural language. I mean, if you can talk to Alexa in Ijesha accent with all the glory of “H factor” and it recognizes your voice, why can’t you chat with your bank WhatsApp and say “transfer N15,000 to Silifa” and it gets done?

Wondering what happened the previous years and the predictions? Read about my takes for 2018.

I didn't do too bad predicting digital payments for 2018

Last year, I wrote about 10 predictions for digital payments in 2018 (better to read this first). Looking back, I can assure you, my career as a seer hasn’t been as illustrious as I planned it to be. So how bad am I? Let’s take a look at how I scored myself.

Alat gets a (bigger) challenger (Score = 1)
Every bank looked at Alat and moved on. Not a single initiative came out to challenge the dominant digital bank which continues to garner critical acclaims world-wide. Likes of dot.bank and Wallet.ng are snipping at its heels though.

PSD2 instigates Open Banking (Score = 5)
Open Banking is no longer a swear word in the UK, and it has been primarily replaced by enthusiasm. Quite some countries are now on the open API bandwagon. Bahrain is a new country that published specific guidelines. Despite the excitement, the fire is like a table-warmer and not a bonfire.

Maturity comes to Fintech (Score = 8)
The Nigerian fintech ecosystem has grown significantly over the last 12 months. The growth is best represented by about 5 international fintech conferences done in Lagos to showcase opportunities. Additionally, some odd 5 Nigerian fintechs firms got into YC over the year. Likes of Paystack attracted top international investors like Stripe, Visa, and Tencent. Mines.io and Cellulant raised a ton of cash. What else can we ask for?

Smaller Fintechs instigates price war (Score = 0)
No price war happened. Prices are same. Everyone is cranky.

Bitcoins bubble explodes, killing many (Score = 10)
Last year, BTC was dancing around $20K with investors (real and Babalawos) predicting $100K per coin. Of course, the bubble made a loud splat with values dropping 80% over the last 1 year. Many of my friends who were coin fanatics then have lost their voices. Can’t gloat but don’t equate greed with tech

International players come to lunch (Score = 7)
Opera made a serious inroad into Nigeria with the launch of Opera news that now has 28m active users. The company will also start to lend to all my cousins soon.  Stripe and Tencent are also putting a tiny toe via Paystack. Please come! We will take care of you.

Android supports pay with Paga (Score = 0)
Nothing happened. Sorry, come back later.

Fraudsters get a beating (Score = 0)
Nothing changed. Stop Fraud Africa floundered and never launched. People are still getting scalped day-in-day-out.

Retail digital lending become prevalent (Score = 7)
Digital lending is on a tear with likes of Mines.io getting $13m to play. But with just 0.77% of all loans going to individuals, the journey is still very far!

AI to the customer service’ rescue (Score = 0)
You would have thought that the opening of Whatsapp APIs for banking would bring decent AIs to help customers? Fat chance. Practically every implementation has been sub-par. Just someone copying and pasting USSD menu into a chat. Disappointing.

I scored a measly 38 out of 100; which is even less impressive when you considered that I marked myself. Next year, take my predictions with a pinch of salt, but then 38% accuracy about the future is better than most prophets can handle. Maybe I am not so bad after all.

Read the original predictions here: https://dejiolowe.com/2017/12/10-predictions-for-digital-payments-in-2018/ and subscribe to my blog to get other posts whenever I can summon enough energy to write them.

Credit bureaus are holding back digital lending in Nigeria

Accessing credit bureau data in Nigeria is tough for digital lenders due to high costs, poor API integration, and lack of standardized information. Here are some initiatives that could enhance credit bureau services, boosting trust and facilitating greater credit flow.

I was at a recent event organized for alternative lenders, mostly digital lenders serving individuals and SMEs. The engagements were eye-opening even though I was already conversant with most of the issues raised.
Nevertheless, one of the nagging problems kept nagging me after I left that day.

Everyone was complaining about how difficult it was to get access to credit bureau data. Yes, they exist in Nigeria, and about 3 of them (FirstCentral, CRC, and CreditRegistry) have been licensed for operations by the Central Bank of Nigeria. They even have an association, Credit Bureau Association of Nigeria (proper parapo).

I wouldn’t jump the gun to blame the credit bureaus, but the complaints that kept coming from different actors (banks, MFBs, individuals, etc.) were so many they cannot be without some attributions. There ain’t no smoke without fire.

Here are some of the critical issues that lenders raised.

Cost

The cost charged per record by the credit bureau is so high as to make it useless except for the high ticket transactions. Meanwhile, digital lenders lend from the low thousands, and when you aren’t giving credit to everyone you check, the cost becomes a runaway train.

On the flip side, credit bureaus get this data from banks and lenders for free then turn around and sell at an exorbitant price per check. This doesn’t make sense to me or anyone else for that matter.

If digital retail lending will ever explode in Nigeria, the cost of checking credit bureaus has to be so low that it is marginal. Probably in the region of N20 to N50 per call. Do that for 10 million calls a month, and you have a N6B business a year.

APIs

Without APIs, there is no credit bureau intermediation in digital lending. APIs must be simple to integrate with, extremely stable, and always available. In a modern digital finance world, APIs should take a few seconds and not days to apply for. There should be a sandbox to test without having to contact anyone.

The APIs currently provided by credit bureaus are so poorly implemented – they are buggy, slow, and takes forever to integrate. You can imagine these credit bureau struggling with modern technology. It is interesting to note that none of the credit bureaus has any reference to APIs on its website; so if you want to see developer documentation, you are on your own!

Information

Information should be simple. In the US and other countries, a combination of names and other demographic info are used. In Nigeria, there should be a standard use for BVN. It is unambiguous; it’s simple, it’s fast

Reduced cost for contributors

Credit bureaus should give credit of say, five free checks for every record of the contribution made by lenders. It offers incentives for lenders to contribute information. The more they update, the cheaper their operations are. It’s a win-win for everyone.

Partnership with fintechs

It’s possible that these credit bureaus have dinosaur backends and find it difficult to serve the fast-paced digital lending world. They could partner with fintechs (hungry for revenue) to build smart API front ends and developer portals which alternative and digital lenders can connect with. Revenue share is a way to make everyone happy. Any takers?

What happens when these are done

Lenders get to trust the system, and it becomes self-reinforcing. The better the system is, the higher the chances of blocking bad actors. When bad actors are getting barred, anyone (like my cousins) with a propensity to go rogue becomes serious because they can see consequences. Then default rates go down which makes interest rates go down as well. More credit flows. Maybe Nigeria can be great again.

Fun facts

Of the three credit bureaus in Nigeria, two are led by ladies. Amazing Amazons

Finding data in Africa shouldn't be a problem. Let's solve it

Accessing reliable data in Africa is tough, leading to reliance on outdated or foreign sources. This hampers business decisions. Efforts to compile and share accessible data are crucial, especially in sectors like Nigerian payments.

Data is the fuel of decision making, anywhere and everywhere; and Africa is not excluded. Regrettably, getting simple information to make intelligent decisions in Africa is so hard you are better off just reading the stars. No wonder most African businesses are based on “divine inspirations.”

The African economy is vast with different sectoral opportunities. Yet, the lord helps you finding accessible information to help you bring your nice ideas to the market. In the end, unfortunately, most of us depend on foreign data or information to make our business decisions. Some of these data are so old the web pages have gray hairs.

Many of my friends (I have so many, want some?) complain about the paucity of data and love to compare how easy it is to get data about other countries. But hey, angels didn’t create the data for them, they did. What we lack is a deliberate attempt to do research, surface insights and share data with the world, for free.

The exciting thing is, if you push data out, you end up becoming a reference or an authority even if some or all of what you published is rubbish. Remember, never believe everything you see on the internet.

The irony is that some data exist but in forms that are not discoverable. For example, I was recently looking for a list of approved mobile money operators in Nigeria. While I know it must be somewhere, hiding and eating popcorn on the CBN website, it wasn’t coming up on Google search.

And when you see some of these data, they are also not easy to understand forms. Data from National Bureau of Statistics (a rich source of good quality data) come in formats so ugly it wouldn’t find a girlfriend if it were a man.
My specialties have always been technology, banking, and payments, so, over the next few weeks, time permitting, I will be prettifying some of the easy information about Nigerian payments space which can then be found by anyone sleuthing around and hopefully Google and Bing can easily surface them as well.

Mobile Money in Nigeria: Operators, Opportunities and Trends

Recently I started seeing a spike in the number of inquiries made by friends, fintechs, and random other people about Mobile Money in Nigeria. And it’s not because they are suddenly having altruistic ideas for financial inclusion. Something must be cooking!

Let’s get the basics right
Mobile money is a form of banking where your account number is your mobile number. It’s as simple as that. Any other definition is an oversabi.
After the successful debut of mPesa in Kenya, many countries tried to launch their copycat mobile money system.

Unfortunately, it has been a mostly miserable failure. Some stats said less than 3% of all mobile money implementation has been successful. In Nigeria, the number is worse: 0%.

At the start of the mobile money madness, CBN gave out 23 licenses, 10 of which were by banks.

After a flurry of activities, things chilled. Banks subsequently developed acute amnesia about their licenses went back to their bread and butter: Commercial Banking.

Why and how mobile money failed will always be contentious. I have written about it, others have different opinions. The one thing we ain’t arguing about though is the fact that mobile money failed to hit the sweet spot.

New interests in Mobile Money
The emergence of fintechs has thrown open new possibilities of what can be done with moribund mobile money licenses. Most fintechs within the payment space are having a lorry load of challenges connecting to banks.
For example, a common request would be funding of payment transactions from bank accounts for which banks haven’t provided any simple APIs to work with. Those doing savings and personal financial management want to keep money in a legal way and also allow topping off investments from bank accounts. That is another problem.

Just like the way banks repurposed USSD codes meant for mobile money in 2014, fintechs are circling around banks to see how mobile money can be repurposed for better things.
 
Now, the list
Getting the actual list of licensed mobile money operators in Nigeria should be simple, right? Nope! You can’t even find it on CBN website if you search for it but here’s the direct link.
So, I put together the list of those I know to aid anyone.

OperatorOwnerWebsite
*909# Mobile MoneyStanbic IBTC Plchttp://www.stanbicibtc.com/
Access mobile moneyAccess Bank Plchttps://www.accessbankplc.com/
TinggCellulant Limitedhttps://tingg.com.ng/
Diamond mobileDiamond Bank Plchttp://www.diamondbank.com/
EazyMoneyZenith Bankhttp://www.eazymoney.com.ng
Ecobank Mobile MoneyEcobankhttps://ecobank.com/
FETSFunds and Electronics Transfer Solution Limitedhttp://www.mywallet.fets.com.ng
Fidelity Mobile MoneyFidelity Bank Plchttps://www.fidelitybank.ng
FirstMonieFirst Bank Nigeria Plchttp://www.firstbankplc.com/
Fortis Mobile MoneyFortis MFBhttp://www.fortismobilemoney.com/
GTMobileMoneyGTBank Plchttps://www.gtbank.com/
Mimo
*Part of Vanso. Bought over by Interswitch in 2016
Interswitch Limited (formerly mKudi, a subsidiary of Vanso)https://www.mimo.com.ng/
Monitize
*Not operational. Site redirects to Fiserv
Monitizehttp://monitise.com/nigeria
NowNowContec Global Infotech Limitedhttp://nownow.ng/
PagaPagaTech Limitedhttp://www.pagatech.com/
PayAttitudeUnified Payments Services Limitedhttps://payattitude.com/
PIDO
*Bought by Opera from Telnet in 2017
Opera Softwarehttp://www.paycom-ng.com/
PocketMonieTranzact Plchttp://www.pocketmoni.com/
QikQik
*Inactive
Eartholeum Networks Limitedhttp://www.eartholeum.com
ReadyCashParkway Projects Limitedhttp://www.readycash.com.ng/
Sterling mobile moneySterling Bank Plchttps://www.sterlingbankng.com/
Teasy MobileTeasy Mobile Limitedhttp://teasymobile.com
U-Mo
*Shut down. License allegedly returned to CBN
Afripay Limited/United Bank for Africa Plchttp://www.umo.net/
Virtual Terminal NetworkVTNetwork Limitedhttps://www.virtualterminalnetwork.com/
Wari
*Senegalese company. Acquired license in 2016
Warihttps://www.wari.com/
Zoto
*Zoto app shut down
Hedonmarks Management Serviceshttps://zoto.com.ng

 
Other documents
The following are also critical documents for mobile money in Nigeria, especially from the regulatory perspective: